Reviewer Guidelines

1. Introduction

As a reviewer, your contribution is vital in maintaining the quality and integrity of this journal. Peer review ensures that only high-quality, well-researched, and ethically sound papers are published.

---

2. Responsibilities of a Reviewer

• Maintain confidentiality of the manuscript.
• Provide a fair, unbiased, and timely review.
• Evaluate the manuscript’s scientific and technical merit.
• Give constructive feedback to help authors improve the paper.
• Declare conflicts of interest, if any.

---

3. Timeline for Review

• Acknowledge the invitation to review within 3 days.
• Submit the review report within 2–3 weeks of acceptance.
• Request extension if needed, or inform the editor if you are unavailable.

---

4. Key Aspects to Evaluate

1. Originality: Is the work novel and significant in the field?
2. Technical Soundness: Are the methods and analysis appropriate and rigorous?
3. Clarity: Is the writing clear, organized, and grammatically correct?
4. References: Are the citations relevant and sufficient?
5. Figures & Tables: Are visuals relevant, accurate, and well-explained?
6. Ethics & Integrity: Are there any signs of plagiarism or unethical conduct?

---

5. Review Report Format

• Confidential comments to the editor
• Comments to the author (constructive, specific, and respectful)
• Recommendation:
  • Accept
  • Minor Revision
  • Major Revision
  • Reject

---

6. Conflict of Interest

• Reviewers must avoid reviewing manuscripts from close collaborators.
• Do not use unpublished data for personal research.
• Do not breach confidentiality.

---

7. Reviewer Ethics

• Do not attempt to contact authors directly.
• Provide evidence and reasoning for critiques.
• Avoid personal criticism.

---

8. Reviewer Recognition

• A certificate of appreciation will be provided.
• Reviewer's name may be published annually (with consent).
• High-performing reviewers may be considered for editorial board roles.

---

9. Communication

If in doubt or if you suspect plagiarism or ethical concerns, contact the editorial office immediately.